Tomorrow's tangle — Inside the Classic

(0 User reviews) 257

In Category - Adventure Picaresque Fiction

Authors: Bonner, Geraldine, 1870-1930, Keller, Arthur Ignatius, 1866-1924 [Illustrator] Digital Source: Project Gutenberg Gutenberg Release Year: 2022 First Publication Year: Not confirmed

Key Word: Miners -- Fiction; Frontier and pioneer life -- Fiction; San Francisco (Calif.) -- Fiction; Singers -- Fiction Target Reader: Readers of public-domain and historical texts

Book Edition: Project Gutenberg digital edition Book Language: en

Edition facts

Words 125,211

Reading time 545 min

Text sections 43

Before opening Tomorrow's tangle — Inside the Classic, the edition data offers a quick orientation: 125,211 words, 9 hr 5 min estimated reading time, and 43 detected text sections.

The text analysis averages about 15.3 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.

Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “Miners -- Fiction,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.

Source: Project Gutenberg record #67521

Bonner's novel uses stark desert imagery and clipped dialogue to expose a secret past in 1850s Utah and San Francisco, where a singer's identity is tied to a woman bought for a pair of horses.

Editorial Edition Score 4.9/5

★★★★★ ★★★★★

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

How this score is calculated

Description quality20 pts
Title & short description10 pts
Source metadata20 pts
Text length15 pts
Chapters / structure15 pts
EPUB file integrity20 pts

Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.

Edition quality

File: pg67521

Read the Text

end to labors and profits had spurred them to unremitting exertion. In a box under Moreau’s bunk there were six small buckskin sacks of dust, joint profits of the summer’s toil.

Moreau, a muscular, fair-haired giant of a man, was that familiar figure of the early days--the gentleman miner. He was a New Englander of birth and education, who had come to California in the first rush, with a little fortune wherewith to make a great one. Luck had not been with him. This was his first taste of success. Five months before he had picked up a “pard” in Sacramento, and after the careless fashion of the time, when no one sought to inquire too closely into another’s antecedents, joined forces with him and spent a wandering spring, prospecting from bar to bar and camp to camp. The casual words of an Indian had directed them to the cañon where now the creak of their rocker filled the hot, drowsy days.

Of Harney Fletcher, Moreau knew nothing. He had met him in a lodging-house in Sacramento, and the partnership proved to be a successful one. What the New Englander furnished in money, the other made up in practical experience and general handiness. It was Fletcher who had constructed the rocker on an improved model of his own. His had been the directing brain as well as the assisting hand which had built the cabin of logs that surveyed the stream bed from a knoll above. The last remnants of Moreau’s fortune had stocked it well, and there were two good horses in the brush shed behind it.

It was now September, and the leaves of the aspens that grew along the stream bed were yellowing. But the air was warm and golden with sunshine. Above, in the high places of the Sierra, where the emigrant trail crept along the edges of ravines and crawled up the mighty flank of the wall that shuts the garden of California from the desert beyond, the snow was already deep. Fletcher, who had gone into Hangtown the week before for provisions, had come back full of stories of the swarms of emigrants pouring down the main road and its branching trails, higgledy-piggledy, pell-mell, hungry, gaunt, half clad, in their wild rush to enter the land of promise.

There was no suggestion of winter here. The hot air was steeped in the aromatic scents that the sun draws from the mighty pines which clothe the foothills. At midday the little gulley where the men worked was heavy with them. All about them was strangely silent. The pines rising rank on rank stirred to no passing breezes. There was no bird note, and the stream had shrunk so that its spring-time song had become a whisper. Heat and silence held the long days, when the red dust lay motionless on the trail above, and the noise made by the rocker sounded strangely intrusive and loud in the enchanted stillness that held the landscape.

On an afternoon like this the men were working in the stream bed--Moreau in the pit, Fletcher at his place by the rocker. There was no conversation between them. The picture-like dumbness of their surroundings seemed to have communicated itself to them. Far above, glittering against the blue, the white peaks of the Sierra looked down on them from remote, aërial heights. The tiny thread of water gleamed in its wide, unoccupied bed. Save the men, the only moving thing in sight was a hawk that hung poised in the sky above, its winged shadow floating forward and pausing on the slopes of the gulch.

Into this spellbound silence a sound suddenly broke--a sound unexpected and unwished for--that of a human voice. It was a man’s, harsh and loud, evidently addressing cattle. With it came the creak of wheels. The two partners listened, amazed and irresolute. The trail that passed their cabin was an almost unknown offshoot from the main highway. Then, the sounds growing clearer, they scrambled up the bank. Coming down the road they saw the curved top of a prairie schooner that formed a background for the forms of two skeleton horses, beside which walked a man who urged them on with shouts and blows. Wagon and horses were enveloped in a cloud of red dust.

Continue Reading →

The novel opens with a tableau of stillness: a dying child on the Utah desert, the canvas of an emigrant wagon the only white spot on a gray expanse. Bonner’s prose in the prologue is deliberately spare, matching the landscape’s “dead indifference.” The heat is a “brazen arch,” the road a “scar across a haggard face.” This is not mere scene-setting; it establishes a world where human transactions are as stark as the terrain. Later, in a San Francisco saloon, the revelation that a woman was “bought from Shackleton for a pair of horses” is delivered in the same flat, unemotional tone. The dialogue, with its colloquial rhythms (“I seen him,” “calkalated to make her ride”), contrasts sharply with the descriptive passages, signaling a tension between raw frontier speech and the narrator’s more literary voice.

Diction and the Weight of Silence

Bonner’s word choice in the desert prologue emphasizes exhaustion and erasure: the earth is “lean, sapless,” the child’s breathing “a defiance in the silence.” Verbs are minimal; the scene is held in a static present. This linguistic economy carries into dialogue. When Harney recounts the purchase of a woman, he says, “I’m not sayin’ how he could; I’m sayin’ what he did.” The repetition of “sayin’” and the blunt syntax refuse moral commentary. The narrator, too, withholds judgment, letting the facts sit. The effect is a kind of documentary flatness that forces the reader to supply the emotional weight. Bonner often uses short, declarative sentences for revelations: “Bought her from Shackleton for a pair of horses.” No exclamation, no elaboration. The silence around these words becomes part of the story.

Voice and Social Register

The excerpts show a clear division between the narrator’s voice and the characters’ speech. The narrator uses formal, even literary constructions: “Crushed between that dead indifference of earth and sky, its participators seemed to feel the hopelessness of movement or plaint.” Characters, by contrast, speak in a Western vernacular marked by dropped g’s (“workin’,” “goin’”), double negatives (“weren’t no good”), and regional idioms (“the worst lookin’ outfit you’ve ever clapped your eyes on”). This register shift is not merely decorative; it signals class and education. The miner Harney, who delivers the key secret, speaks in a rough, repetitive style, while Essex, the listener, is given no direct speech in the excerpt. Bonner uses dialect to establish authority: Harney’s knowledge is grounded in experience, not schooling. The contrast also hints at the social tensions that will likely drive the plot.

Recurring Details: The Desert and the Transaction

Two images recur across the excerpts: the desert as a space of death and the transaction of a human being. The prologue’s desert is “gaunt and sterile,” a place where “one of the thousand tragedies the desert had seen” unfolds. This landscape is not just setting but a moral condition—a world where life is cheap. The transaction—a woman bought for two horses—is described in the same matter-of-fact tone as the desert’s heat. Harney says, “Bought her from Shackleton for a pair of horses,” and Essex asks, “How could he?” The answer is simply “I’m not sayin’ how he could; I’m sayin’ what he did.” The desert’s indifference to human suffering is mirrored in the characters’ acceptance of such bargains. Bonner does not explain or justify; she presents the fact as a fact, leaving the reader to feel the weight of that silence.

Structure and the Unfolding Secret

The novel’s structure, as indicated by the chapter titles, moves from the desert prologue to a section titled “Mariposa Lily” and then to chapters set in San Francisco. The secret of the protagonist’s parentage is revealed not in the opening but through a retrospective conversation in a saloon. This delayed disclosure is a structural choice: the reader first experiences the desert’s desolation, then later learns its consequence. The chapter titles themselves hint at a romantic or operatic arc—“The Enchanted Winter,” “The Prima Donna”—but the excerpts suggest a grittier foundation. Bonner withholds the full story, letting the reader piece together the implications of Harney’s tale. The epilogue, titled “The Prima Donna,” suggests a resolution that may return to the theme of performance and identity, but the excerpts do not reveal how.

Bonner’s novel rewards attention to its silences—the gaps between what is said and what is implied. The desert prologue and the saloon confession are linked by a shared refusal to sentimentalize. Readers should note how the author uses physical detail (the wagon’s shadow, the miner’s glass of whiskey) to anchor emotional revelations. The vernacular speech is not merely local color but a tool for character revelation. Approach the text as a study in how people talk around the unspeakable.

That desert loneliness in Tomorrow's Tangle stayed with me long after—the way a voice can carry so much unspoken weight. It reminded me of the quiet ache I felt flipping through Cactus and Rattlers — Key Ideas to Explore last month. Both left me staring at the ceiling, thinking about the marks we hide from everyone, even ourselves.